"Top-rated" gets slapped on everything these days, so what does it actually mean for a Newark-to-Manhattan ride? Talk to enough travelers and the same handful of things keep coming up. On-time pickup, obviously. Sounds basic, but it's the number one reason people leave bad reviews. A driver working off your actual flight status — not a scheduled time from days ago — is far less likely to leave you standing around, or worse, just miss you entirely. Then there's the car itself. After a nine-hour flight, a clean vehicle with working AC and a driver who grabs your bags without being asked matters more than people expect going in. It's a small thing until you're the one who's exhausted. Pricing that doesn't surprise you. The quote you got should be the number you pay — tolls included, unless someone told you otherwise up front. Services that tack on fees at drop-off get remembered, and not in a good way.